I KNOW Giri sir has repeated that bhav chalit should be used to see house and rashi chart to see sign.
Still I am asking this question because I always see even big Jyotishis like Giri sir himself or PVNR sir or Rahul Kaushik sir open a chart, and start making bhaav based predictions based on rashi chart alone (“lagna lord is in 9th house so it is a Raja Yoga…”, etc.)
Very rarely do I see anybody change the chart to Bhav chalit and verifying. Some people say Bhav chalit placements influence result somewhat but in Parasari we should mostly see Rashi chart, etc.
Please if somebody has experience of which is correct, please give one authoritative answer
Thank you for your answer Firstly, i don't know why you assumed i am advising anyone. Can you point to where I am advising legends like PVNR sir or Giri sir? Second, please read carefully... ok they do not need to open chalit chart to know bhava placement, but for example if lagnesh is going into 9tRead more
Thank you for your answer
Firstly, i don’t know why you assumed i am advising anyone. Can you point to where I am advising legends like PVNR sir or Giri sir?
Second, please read carefully… ok they do not need to open chalit chart to know bhava placement, but for example if lagnesh is going into 9th rashi but into 8th house in chalit, they don’t consider it to be 8th house but say “it’s a rajayoga and that gives good fruit”. THAT is the source of my confusion.
I have noticed this many times on videos of different jyotishis not just one, even real life jyotishis during reading (one of Giri sir’s students also), further some people claim that chalit only gives 15% result, 85% result is from rashi chart and so chalit is not so important in parasari jyotish… thus I wanted authoritative answer from Giri sir’s community
My entire life when I try to respect gurus also they think i’m acting smart? May be due to mangal or rahu in my 9th house… Anyway hope my question is clear now
See lessin my humble opinion, when you quote that Shri PVNR sir or Giri Sir are not checking bhav or any other seniors are not checking bhav but advising to check bhav chart remember firstly - for them with experience and checking more than 100 charts they can see the degree of planet in lagna chart and gagRead more
in my humble opinion, when you quote that Shri PVNR sir or Giri Sir are not checking bhav or any other seniors are not checking bhav but advising to check bhav chart remember firstly – for them with experience and checking more than 100 charts they can see the degree of planet in lagna chart and gage if the planet is falling in cusp degree or not it comes with experience of reading multiple charts…even a certain degree will tell you which navansh placement or if cusp degree then confirm in bhav…hence please don’t abruptly doubt the actions first observe which situations they are checking and which situations they are not checking and how confidently they are making mind calculation abt where the planet falls in bhav charts…this comes with experience of studying multiple charts…you also try and with time you will be able to gage when to check and when no need to check if you know by hearted…hope this clarified
See lessyou have totally misunderstood the question. please read it calmly. can you show me where i adviced them anything? again ill clarify for you - degrically also if a planet goes to 8th house, but is in 9th house in rashi chart, they many times consided it to be 9th house. them having skill to tell plaRead more
you have totally misunderstood the question. please read it calmly.
can you show me where i adviced them anything?
again ill clarify for you – degrically also if a planet goes to 8th house, but is in 9th house in rashi chart, they many times consided it to be 9th house. them having skill to tell planet house from degree etc is not relevant, i am saying they dont consider bhav chalit position. PVNR sir releases analyses every month you can easily see this. Same with Giri sir in many videos…
BECAUSE many jyotishis say to consider only Rashi chart for Parasari jyotish THATS why i am asking (not advising) which is correct
See lessin the whole answer you only focused on the word "advised" ...if you hv seen giri sirs videos so well then you should also know how you are failing to see the answer because of the mercurial way of interpreting knowledge...sad..such way people hv difficulties in learning...narrow minded focus...guruRead more
in the whole answer you only focused on the word “advised” …if you hv seen giri sirs videos so well then you should also know how you are failing to see the answer because of the mercurial way of interpreting knowledge…sad..such way people hv difficulties in learning…narrow minded focus…gurus always gv 1 Sutra and students hv to themselves try on multiple charts and apply it on various combinations but if your focus is on 1 word and not the content also coming forward with debating mindset without analysing real time charts and practicing then such people always have problems in learning….anyways best of luck to you with your answer search…maybe you are not ready for the truth but want to hear the answer you hv set in your mind.. jai mahadev maa gauri
See less